The X-Files Season 8 & 9 + I Want to Believe Movie Review
The Jacked Up Review Show PodcastOctober 27, 2026
1404
01:18:0571.5 MB

The X-Files Season 8 & 9 + I Want to Believe Movie Review

We dive into Seasons 8 & 9 of X-FILES plus the always divisive second movie:

 

*Could the 2nd movie had just been a reformatted two-part episode where they take on a serial killer cult & get rid of the pedophile priest subplot?

 

*Why should every fan conclude with the Season 8 as the ACTUAL final season?

 

*If Season 9 had just been the stand-alone episodes and cool finale, would it be better regarded?

 

*Despite the controversial follow-up seasons, what other factors make Season 9 STILL the weakest installment to date?

 

*We also talk about an infamous X-Files review book that boggle's one's mind in why said "author" is even a fan!

 

 

 

GUESTS:

John Holman, Ethan Weeks & Oreo Brewer

 

ADDITIONAL SEGMENTS BY:

Adam Silva, X-FIles Storyteller, X-FIles Blue and Andrea Thomas

 

BONUS MATERIAL BY:

Bloggers John Kenneth Muir, Sohan Sahoo & Gabriel Ricard

[00:00:00] This podcast is a production of Unfiltered Studios. If you would like to know more about joining Unfiltered Studios, please visit our website at unfpod.com for more information. So once again, we're getting into the thick of it. Just where again, I know some will say, Oh, stop while you're ahead. It's like, No, we're not stopping ahead. We're gonna examine just what can you like? What can, what do you hate? Why everything just varies.

[00:00:29] The way it does. So, again, here we are at Season 8. This is the first season with Robert Patrick as Agent John Doggett. It's a whole new arc where Scully's pregnancy is formed mysteriously. She's had no contact with any human prior.

[00:00:52] And then Mulder's alien induction. Will they find him? It's to accommodate both David Duchovny having a dispute on the profit as well as wanting to expand his movie career. Most people, fans are gonna regard this as a good season for even some who weren't crazy about the Mulder seasons, believe it or not. But we'll get into that even more. There's 10 mythology episodes on this season.

[00:01:20] Man. And it was surprisingly well received by critics, but fans, some of them are just giving it up at that point. And they also make use of giving a wrap, some wrap up episodes for the lone gunman who had their own show at this point. We are also introduced to Annabeth Gish of Mystic Pizza fame as Agent Reyes, Monica Reyes. And let's look at the score.

[00:01:50] You know, season eight was also just good at establishing John Doggett needs to find out why his son was killed years ago and what it was like for him being a former New York police officer. And a search for the end and everything will not remain the same as it was.

[00:02:13] And so season eight, it's a 3.79 on Serial Lies. Pretty rough, but it has a 67% from nine critic scores as well as a 74% user score. Now season nine of the X-Files. This is the divisive one.

[00:02:41] You're either still in it or you've given it up by then. Season nine has. Man. So at this point. It has seven mythology episodes, not as many serialized stuff they're doing. They're probably at their strongest doing standalone stuff. And I say that as one who had issues with several episodes in that. There was a lot of winners, surprisingly, but we'll get to it.

[00:03:08] So at this point, Agent Rays, Doggett, and Scully are hunting down a government conspiracy that involves an elaborate and malevolent creation of the super soldiers. That's right. They got some. They're back to hybrids. And after only appearing in the preceding season, Duchovny did not return. But until the final episode on this, and for good reason.

[00:03:34] And as a fan who was just casually watching it, I kid you not, I got into it in the 2000s. And it was always showing in the morning and evening on both TNT and Sci-Fi Channel. So I saw both the first episode and the final episode that same summer. I was blown away. So, yeah. Mixed reaction from critics and a negative reaction from longtime fans and viewers due to Duchovny's absence.

[00:04:04] But during this year, the ratings for the season fell dramatically. Critics blamed it on what they considered an increasingly incoherent story arc, while the cast and crew ascribed their drop in viewership to the September 11th attacks. Regardless, Fox eventually wanted to cancel the show. They gave a finale. But, yeah. They gave some closure in season 9. My bad, not season 8.

[00:04:32] And the rating on Rotten Tomatoes leaves a lot to be desired. Basically, at this point, it's a 22% on Rotten Tomatoes based off 9 ratings and a 57% user score. So, yeah. All it took was like four crappy reviews and like two positives. But even the DVD talk site doesn't have much nice to say about it.

[00:05:01] So, going into, it's got a free .19 on Serialized. And it just keeps getting lower from there for those next seasons. As for the movie, that came out in 2008. So, right after 2002, so six years after, they've already come out with their second video game. They come out with toys and merchandise. Comics. They only get even more comics after that.

[00:05:30] So, there's plenty of fan sites. The DVDs are doing good. So, Chris Carter, the creator, co-writes with head writer Frank Spotsnitz. And directs. He's done it before, but he directs the second movie. And it follows Scully and Mulder in this standalone story just reuniting.

[00:05:55] And basically, you know, Mulder needs something to do. And Scully's, once again, teaching students. They're called back to duty by the FBI when a former priest, who's a sex offender, claims to be receiving psychic visions pertaining to a kidnapped federal agent. The movie rates a 5.9 out of 10 on IMDb.

[00:06:22] It had a 47% out of 100 score on Metacritic. It's got a 6.6 out of 10 for the audience. Nevertheless, it's a 2.9 out of 5 on Letterboxd. And on All Movie, it has surprisingly the same score on All Movie as they did for the first movie, Fight the Future. A 2.5 out of 5 stars.

[00:06:49] And a 3 out of 5 user score. Let's go to Rotten Tomatoes because that's the first one you're going to see. That's a 32% on Rotten Tomatoes by 167 critics' reviews. It is the same score, surprisingly, 32% for the user score as well. So all across the board. And once again, we're going to validate you guys. We're going to get into the good. We're going to get into the bad. Either way, we're going to explain what resonated and what didn't.

[00:07:18] Enjoy this season 8 through 9 plus the second movie review. I think everyone hates on the super soldiers, but it's so funny now. Kind of like with New Star Trek. I'm seeing a lot of people hate on the last two X-Files seasons. And I get it. Yeah, either like it or you don't like it. But that's how all fandoms are. They're just like how all the Star Wars fans were like, they hated the prequels. But then when the sequel trilogy came out, now they like the prequels.

[00:07:46] Now they're like, oh, the prequels were real Star Wars. Not like these stupid movies now. All fandoms are the same. All fandoms have the same issues that come up. I'm seeing people. Absolutely. I remember people bashing the super soldiers and that was kind of the same deal. I was like, well, not the greatest effects, but it's still kind of interesting. And Riot and Rays have kind of become fan favorites.

[00:08:13] So it's just interesting how those two Fed agents, they were kind of, again, just people just wanted to compare, even though they weren't even written at all. Like, yeah, I was a big fan of, especially Doggett, both Doggett and Rays. I think Robert Patrick and Annabeth Gish, they got so unfairly maligned during those last two seasons by fans who, you know, just couldn't accept anybody new. But I do think in recent years, I think they, the actors I'm talking about, I think they didn't think anybody liked them.

[00:08:40] I think in recent years when we've had these like fan conventions that have popped up, they've gone to them and they've seen that they do have fans out there. And I think that's, that's nice that they've, they've seen that there actually were, you know, you know, the, the internet, you know, whatever you're talking about, whether it's culture or politics or whatever, the loudest voices in the room always dominate. So whoever's trashing something, whoever is, you know, like the worst people, those are the people who stick out.

[00:09:07] And those don't necessarily match up with, you know, the majority of fans. I mean, you know, so I think it's, you know, it's, it's, it was not, it's nice for them to have gotten some renewed. And as you said, you know, because of people have had problems with the revival, they've gone back and been like, oh yeah, seasons eight, nine weren't, weren't that bad. We really like those now. So you do have some of that effect as well. Season eight is, I think are a really good season.

[00:09:35] Season nine, I still, you know, I still think I would probably rate it probably towards the bottom, but I do think it has, I do think it has some, some episodes, especially some of the standalone episodes, like 4D or John Doe, Hellbound, Audrey Polly, Improbable Release. They're all, those are some, those are some really good episodes. And it's like, if, if those that had Mulder and Scully, some of those would be considered classics, I think. So, you know, it's just people weren't paying attention as much because

[00:10:04] of, you know, David had left the show and also 9-11 happened. People weren't really feeling the X-Files anymore. That's what I noticed with every good show. Yeah. And I don't even know how people got any kind of ratings going because it just seemed like just about every other show just wasn't being watched as much. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, yeah, that's probably a fair point. I mean, I think people kept it on, but they just wouldn't know it because they were just constantly, you know, showing on TV.

[00:10:32] And I was always just kind of like, that's where I saw it with just any show, really. Just so many cable networks were just re-airing, you know, the network shows. Right. It's even funnier because then you realize how more violent it was than it, you were actually used to. Because, you know, unless you, you know, stayed up late, you didn't really realize, oh yeah, this is still pretty edgy TV. Yeah.

[00:10:59] I think seasons 8 and 9 were the first to have viewer discretion advised warnings since that home episode. Because after the home episode, the censors really, you know, they bit down on the writers and they kind of, you know, I wouldn't say neutered the show, but they said, yeah, you can't do any stuff like that anymore. But I think in those later seasons when those people were paying attention

[00:11:27] again, I think they got away with maybe a little bit more. Maybe that's why it returned to some of its darker roots. So yeah, that's an interesting point. It's so weird. It's like they want them to do it. And then at the same time, they don't want them to do it. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. The hypocrisy of censors is, I think, renowned. But, you know. Yeah. It's like they're either afraid that someone will watch it or that are bullshit. It's, I mean, kind of the same with these other procedurals.

[00:11:55] It seemed like CSI was the only one that people bitched about briefly, but everyone was watching it. So they just stopped complaining. Right. Yeah. If it's, if it's a big enough hit there. I've never heard anyone complain about criminal minds. That's the weird thing. So I guess it was just that late enough of the night. And again, like you say, kind of an X-Files kind of crowd. Yeah. And I don't know how, I don't know how Hannibal was on NBC. Like that show was so beyond what. I saw people. I was seeing my channels.

[00:12:22] But I think they used the sort of X-Files tricks and like they somehow got away with the horror because of like the, the artistic nature of it. And like the cinematography and like tricks that they used from X-Files and Millennium. Yeah. Yeah. They, they, they really got away with it, but yeah, that was, that was a great show. I do miss that show as well. So. I guess because of that show is popular enough, you know, it's already based off of preexisting, you know,

[00:12:47] set of books and a movie that various movie versions to where it had enough to just kind of already find its feet. But like you say, it is just like, it's never consistent when criticism goes down and half the time people just want to complain for the sake of complaining. But I do know. Sure. Yeah. As another note, it is interesting how both internal lines and X-Files will kind of take something that you could have sworn could have back in the day, probably been a seventies, you know,

[00:13:15] drive in scary feature or 80 slash. Yeah. And they'll do something more with it. The truth. It's going. We will find him. The obsession. What did you do to her? Sully. The miracle. You're going to have this baby and I'm going to do everything I can to protect it. The X-Files on season eight on DVD today. The only thing more shocking than how it began. This is greater than you or me. Is how it will end. They will use the truth against us. Mulder.

[00:13:45] The final season of the X-Files. Own it on DVD today.

[00:13:50] So welcoming for this part of seasons eight and nine and the second movie.

[00:14:41] I want to believe we got movie buff himself, Ethan Weeks. Welcome back. How you doing? And movie shark, as he likes to call him, John Hallman. Hey, what's going on brother? Just validating everybody. These have been super positive chats. We were all varying on which plot arcs we did or didn't like. And it was like, but at the end of the day, we all agree it's a good show to prepare for this. I even went back to the last two seasons and was like, here's the thing with X-Files.

[00:15:10] It's kind of more alternate endings than Star Wars. You have to decide where it ends in your heart. You know, like we've kind of done that with Star Wars. Does it end with new Jedi order? Does it end with return of the Jedi? What does it end with dark empire? I'm this way with X-Files. It's like, I kind of want to end with season eight. Others prefer to end with season nine. Many pretend the second movie doesn't exist. I like those four parters of that final X-Files stuff,

[00:15:37] but they still introduced season 10 and 11, but they introduced other stuff where I'm like, I don't like that plot twist at all. I can't get behind it. I like seasons eight and nine every episode, actually. I don't like the second movie though. I think it's terrible, but I do. I actually liked every episode of season eight and nine. And fair enough. I mean, and there's always a bad or lesser episode in every season, but I,

[00:16:03] I feel like if you just focus on just the fun mystery arc, she'll have a lot of fun. The first nine seasons, there's actually only one episode. I didn't like, believe it or not. Really? And it's the one with an actor. I really like Michael Massey. I forget to do the Amish or something. I just didn't think the episode worked. Okay. Yeah. The ancestors of Mulder. Yeah. Well, so that's wild. Yeah.

[00:16:32] We were defending all kinds of episodes. It was so funny. So on hated the South African plot arc. I'm like, what are you talking about? And then he was befuddled by the fact that I didn't like the body swap episode. I just don't do cringe comedy very well. So this is so funny. Everyone was varying. A lot of people hate the episode free, which is about Mulder beginning seduced by a vampire and some other stuff. But yeah, it's the ones I love the William Gibson's episodes,

[00:17:01] but everyone loves to hate a first person shooter. I'm like, it's kind of campy. And you got the lone gunman hacking. What, what, where can you go wrong? So Chris Allen one. Oh yes. Chris Allen. Yeah. She was that one. Yeah. I like it. Yeah. It kind of scared me in that one, but yeah. So season eight and nine, I still. It's so weird. We're fans are like. A lot of them. I will admit there are episodes that Chris Carter has done the very creator that I don't care for, but I don't think he's overrated,

[00:17:31] but a lot of people nowadays love to pile on him acting like he's a husband. I kind of admire that he kept it going for as long as he did. And he was, you know, one of the top producers along with, you know, the Steven Bochco, Dick Wolfson, John Wells and David Chase is the world. So. Well, John and Ethan, where do you stand on Chris and his. Empire. You know, the thing is, is I, like we were talking about,

[00:18:00] but when we were going after in season one and two, I, I didn't know that he had done a, as much work that he has. I was looking back through his, his, uh, all the, all the stuff that he's written. And I was, I was actually kind of blown away. And I, and my, my, my, my, my complete recollection was shot on everything that he did. Um, are you talking about before X-Files? Cause I don't even know. I'm sorry.

[00:18:30] He did a, he did a sitcom with Barbara Eden. It was on ABC, but yeah. Yeah. But in between there was in between that millennium and lone gunman, he did harsh realm, which was loosely inspired by a comic. Yeah. Yeah. You guys remember how Robert Patrick, who believe it or not, still to this day, considers this his favorite role as, uh, as Doggett. Uh, what do you make? Yeah. Uh, the, the only thing, uh,

[00:18:58] I thought they missed out on is they should have had Frank black join the cast full time. You know, Lance Hendrickson could have used the work, you know, as profiler, Frank black. Uh, I, I, I think it would, I think he would have been perfect working with the lone gunman as the Robert Patrick. Don't get me wrong. You know, much like Henry said, he is a character, actor. He's done his share of B movies. Uh, but yeah, yeah. Usually he's a bad guy. Like when you see him in cop land or die hard to, uh, what, what do you make of Doggett? Cause like,

[00:19:27] I think it's unfair that people acted like he's a replacement. It was like, he, it's kind of like the law and order detectives. You can't say detective Logan sounds like Briscoe or green or, you know, Benson and Stabler sound the same as Finn and Munch, you know, I was like, that's so unfair, you know, to say he sounds like, I mean, he's not a conspiracy theorist for starters. He's a skeptic, much like Scully was in the first season. And he's like, yeah, this is like, but at least he's not demeaning towards her.

[00:19:57] He just flat out says, Hey, uh, can you give me any other explanation that doesn't involve a monster? And Doggett, right? That's when he was, um, what was he doing? He was investigating the search for Mulder, right? He was looking for, yeah, he becomes the, I got to get, find him. And then it becomes, I guess we're permanent partners. And I mean, don't you just love to be welcomed with coffee being thrown in your face? Oh, yeah. Who doesn't? Yeah. I,

[00:20:24] I think he and raise could have had their own spinoff. They're pretty strong in their own right. I, I love raise. Like, this is the first thing I saw in a Beth Gishon. Like I have seen parts of mystic pizza. I'd seen wider, but yeah, she wasn't a big star that she is now, you know, I still haven't even seen wider. Oh, well, uh, wider. Yeah. Neither are you. Have you. Okay. That's crazy. She was a bit part character actress and now she's had recurring roles. She was a serial killer on Rizzoli and Isles.

[00:20:54] She was this crooked mayor on the recent season, mayor's assistant on a Chicago fire. And she's been on other stuff like brotherhood and West wing as the president's daughters. It was like, yeah. Oh yeah. Brotherhood. That's right. I watched all that. Yeah. Okay. So yeah, that, that would be Jason Clark's wife. Yeah. So you, so you, you, you've seen her, but you don't know her name, but she is a very beautiful brunette. But at the same time, I'm also like, yeah, she's pretty strong. She's very firm in her voice.

[00:21:23] And even though, unfortunately, this is a brownwashing role, she's not, you know, Hispanic or Navajo, but. Right. Right. I guess the ticket played Monica Reyes, right? Yeah. Yeah. And, but despite that, I think it's still a good performance. Uh, I mean, the fact that she's kind of like Scully where she's more reserved, but she agrees with all the, all the supernatural stuff with molder. So I thought that was a perfect combo. Is like, yeah.

[00:21:53] So, uh, Ethan, how would you say they differentiate all the different personas? Cause usually on most detective shows, they have them all like getting in a line. They kind of do what they do on Star Trek where everyone speaks their mind. How do you think they do the profiling differently on these two seasons? Yeah. I wish I remembered. I wish I remembered. Oh my God. Um, and I don't remember like how they were. Well, I do remember how dog,

[00:22:22] it was different from like Mulder. I remember how their relationships were different, but I don't remember like how they dealt with what they were doing. And yeah. Mainly, mainly when they introduce it, that they often have just like, uh, for better or worse that they, they have, you know, raise, we'll discover something or get a solo mission. And, you know, she sees the stuff, but then when the superiors call her on it,

[00:22:51] she tells a white lie, you know, she doesn't cite the supernatural stuff while Scully, you know, it just sticks to the science stuff. Cause again, they're always, you know, now that Mulder is not being here, cause that's the other eye irony is Mulder's both a barrier in the road. And he, because of the department knows he's good, but is so embarrassed by the exposure he gives them. He, he was kind of their last bit of defense. So yeah, it was like,

[00:23:18] they're all having to keep their judgment separate and be like, yeah, somehow this killer got out, even though he couldn't have gotten out in that amount of time. And, uh, but I, I definitely feel like season nine got way more Twilight Zone esque. Like they had way more just standalone stuff. And it was like, you know, that was pretty. Oh yeah. Yeah. Right. Yeah. That's what I, that's my problem is it started getting a little, I don't know. It just started going away from what. A little jaded.

[00:23:48] Yeah. Yeah. A little bit, you know, it just went away from what I loved about X-Files a little bit, but I, you know, I mean, I still watched it. I still watched it. I just, you know, I, I had a hard time following a lot of it. Um, I, I kind of did too as a casual fan. Like I knew something so funny when you're watching it out of order, you can kind of get the different amount of immediacy. It was like, by the time you get, I was really digging eight. And I was like, see,

[00:24:18] eight kind of found its voice pretty much right away. It's like, okay, we've had a year of being angry that, you know, to company called off and sued Fox and Carter's finally getting his credit back together, but he's still got Frank spot. And it's being one of the lead writers and John Chabon contributing more. So, you know, we still don't have Morgan and Wong. They're, they're off doing. I don't have to, I don't know what the drama was with David Duchovny. Actually, Jesus, I don't know.

[00:24:46] It was kind of more just contract disputes and then still wanting to do his own thing. And yeah, I think he should have just gone it another year considering how both he and Jillian had already, you know, had a good compromise, which was at least film in LA, but I get it, you know, it's, and this is where I'm neutral in all this, you know, I'm being a legal guard, you know, messenger. I'm just like, Hey, you know, I didn't live your life. I don't know how hard it is, you know,

[00:25:16] in between all the paparazzi and fans stopping you at a train station. I don't know. So I, but if you're ready to go, sometimes you just got to say, let it be. But in all fairness, they did a solid compromise by just having him be in the first few episodes of eight and pop up now and again. And then nine, he was absent from until the finale. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, that sounds familiar. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I got to say though, I love how season eight is kind of Terminator esque,

[00:25:46] just with the other alien bounty hunters. And one of the things, one of the few things I do remember, even though I liked seasons eight and nine is, I remember there's an episode where Joe Morton guest stars. That was really, that is one of the thinking to myself, wait a minute, Joe Morton, Robert Patrick. Yeah. Totally. two T two, two T two villains in one movie. Yeah. But yeah, that, that one is a perfect, like,

[00:26:14] I think Rod Sterling of twilight zone would have. It just clapped from beyond his grave. It would have been like, you did a perfect groundhog's day episode. You did a fugitive on the run, trying to prove his innocence. Well, and Danny trail gets to be the villain of the week. And you're like, how is, and you got to be keeping up with it. We're going to, we're going to be telling you the clues in reverse chronologic order. So just remember, this is 14 hours later, 12 hours, you know,

[00:26:39] before 11 hours before this excellent next thing. And then the hero is still going to lose one thing because truth be told, he was not a good lawyer, so to speak. He did put an innocent man behind bars. So he, he lives with the fact he did not get framed. His wife did not get murdered. He did not get framed for it, but he still had to do jail time for, or and loses license to practice law. But so I, I like those half and half, you know,

[00:27:09] half victory, half fail, you know, it's just like, it makes it more realistic, more gray area, but, and it is wild how dogged introduces him is like, Hey, you didn't do a good thing as a lot at, under the law, but I still think you're, you meant well, you're still were a good man at heart. You just politics got in the way. They corrupted you. Um, but yeah, um, it is wild how, I mean,

[00:27:35] I kind of dig how you got Adam Baldwin's character. And I like how, you know, I was already a fan cause you know, he just was a regular B movie guy. Then take Adam Baldwin. Which character was Adam Baldwin? Say, say again. Sorry, John. I heard every other word, but. Oh, I was trying to find out what, uh, Baldwin, which, who, uh, he, he, he played, uh,

[00:28:05] yeah, he on X files. He, uh, uh, played. I always forget the character's name. No, no roar. He's, uh, it's, I, I like the personal art because, uh, you know, Patrick's dog, it comes up to him and is like, yeah, we know each other from our time in the military. You're now part of the special black ops unit. You're not the super soldier program. Yeah, actually. Yeah. You're a super soldier program. That's different from the alien bounty hunters, but yeah, it was like he,

[00:28:35] he starts off as his criminal informant. And then after a while, it's very apparent, much like with deep throat and Mr. X is like, uh, you're feeding me some lies, uh, cough up the real truth, but I just, I find it interesting because, you know, this is before he's on castle and SVU and Chuck and last ship at this point, he's just gotten over the cancellation of firefly. You ever, do you know if the show was a day, uh, is it daybreak? And,

[00:29:04] um, I love the inside. Yeah. Daybreak in the inside. They're both good. Pretty good. Those were definitely X files, twilight zone shows, but I mean, at this point, he's still kind of living off of cult fandom from my bodyguard and full metal jacket. And yeah, fireflies on for like another year, but predator too, predator too. He's one of the evils. Uh, so there you go. Maybe, maybe, maybe that's the connection to the alien and predator universe. He's playing. I think that's what it was. Yeah.

[00:29:34] He's what he's part of Gary Busey secret program, but yeah. Wow. I, well, what did you think of him as this villain? Cause I thought they did a good job of making him stand out. He's kind of more smooth while Mr. X is kind of more cynical and deep road is, kind of wise, but not offering much. He's offering riddles. Uh, just some finishing thoughts. one thing I appreciate about the X files and everyone appreciates this, but I'm Mr. Positivity. I think it's cool that you can choose with a consonant.

[00:30:04] Yeah. Cause, but I also like how you can choose how you want to end this saga. Like, it was like, I wasn't crazy about later seasons. I could say it ends with season eight. If you want to, you can say it ends with season nine, or you can say it ends with the comic books, which are the alternate season 10 or 11, or you can say it ends with what we got now, the actual season 10 and 11. So, uh, but I, everyone keeps doing the whole don't bother. I'm like, well, everyone's different, you know,

[00:30:34] for real. It's like, I just saw it casually growing up. So I knew season nine wasn't as hot, but I, there's plenty to enjoy in season eight. Everyone likes to lump them together. Um, where do, where do you come at it? You know, it was like, so what, what did dog it do different and raise do differently from the Mulder and Scully show. And I only have one complaint. And it's like, we need a little more of Skinner. He kind of fades into the background. I get why they faded Skinner out.

[00:31:00] I get that because that was a changing of the guard because Kirsch came in, and he was, he was the evil HNIC for sure. Whereas, you know, Mulder and Scully were so used to Skinner always saving their ass. Kirsch comes in. It's like, no, fuck you. I'm not helping your ass out till later on. Yeah. We got these super soldiers who are very much like the T-1000. They're, they're regenerative. It's like, we're shooting at them and it has zero effect. It's like that.

[00:31:30] This makes zero sense. I'm not even going to explain it because I can't, but, uh, how do you like how he goes from being just, just a reserved hotshot to, it's like, I'm not going to be stuck up anymore. I'm actually gonna get to the bottom of this. I've already been betrayed by my informant. It was one of my military buddies. It was like, no, Hey, he's working with the bad guys. And he was good. I, I loved everybody on X-Files. I didn't hate any. Well, I mean,

[00:31:58] I had that natural hate because they come up, come off as an asshole. It's like, yeah, you're a total asshole. I'm supposed to hate you. What a hysterical greeting is like, Scully's like, Oh, you're going to report place. My partner, she just pours coffee in his face and everyone's like, nice greeting, huh? But, but yeah, raise, I, they kind of do her dirty. Uh, don't get me wrong. I don't think there's any bad seasons. I will say season nine is the weakest, but there's a lot of great standalone ones. Oh, what, what season do you personally?

[00:32:28] Oh, Jesus. I got, I got goosebumps now. Shit. Um, no. Cause like, I'm thinking back and I really was like, I watched this shit when I was on TNT. I never kept up with it on Fox. Like I always look forward to them late nights on TNT. Sci-fi channel. And yeah, they loved it. But yes, I kudos to the super soldier program that that was my only beef grown up. I just didn't find that plot arc interesting.

[00:32:55] That was like a blander free part Star Trek episode, but on. Yeah, it was kind of like universal soldier. And I just, uh, but I actually dig on rewatch. It's kind of more Manchurian candidate ish with the rehealing, but they find ways to differentiate them from the alien bounty hunters who, you know, can be killed different ways, but sometimes, you know, you're not, it's like a vampire. You're not quick enough.

[00:33:24] So they're just going to regenerate anyway. You know, it's like, you got to stake them a certain way. Otherwise, you know, with that particular knife. But I think that was the best way to go is like, just introduce a different kind of hidden evil because, you know, the ones who came from older, they'd taken them. So they, they really don't need to be in the storyline anymore. And which makes sense. Yeah, that's right. Cause you can't like, it goes back to star. It really does. I mean, you can't beat on the,

[00:33:54] the OT forever and expect people to keep coming around. Like, Oh, Luke has a new lightsaber. Vader has a new enemy. Vader has a new power. Luke has new powers. Leia is cool again. Han's awesome. Landers got a new ship. Like nobody fucking cares. At least star Trek would do Bajorans. And now they've done a good job with the Gorn is like, and we'll give you a different board remnant. It was like, okay, good. Cause you've already blown up the five other ones.

[00:34:22] Just have a different one in that space, but don't have the same motherfucker, you know, get healed all over again. This is not something fun, but a little silly on objectively like captain power, where you're having fun. But it's like, of course Lord dread is going to get away still. So it's like, it don't have to be like shredder on Ninja turtles. You know, it's like, it was like shredder. Go back into a, uh, I get the disconnect with shredder. Like you have,

[00:34:51] you have your fans who read the comics, your fans who grew up with the eighties TV show, me and others who grew up with the 90 film and 91 and 93 films. And then everything else later on, the other generations grow with, and I grew up with too. So yeah, I get disconnected with shredder. I get that shit. I still love that motherfucker. He is. I like the character and everything. And kudos to him though. I mean, at least halfway,

[00:35:20] they made us halfway on that one. It was like, okay, just have other people come into, uh, the circle, some of the other mad scientists and other stuff. And then he can come back now that he's healed and found a new Ninja clan. Follows orders. We'll return after these messages. We got a 90 minute weekly shack stop. It's growing all over the world. Find it at 2 PM and 10 PM Eastern time on Mondays,

[00:35:49] then 3 PM on Wednesdays, then 7 PM on Thursdays. You can catch it on many more radio stations, 99.9 KERV, 1 PM central time, 2 PM Eastern on Mondays, then catch the encore on Thursdays at 5 PM central time, 6 PM Eastern. Then catch it Wednesday mornings at 11 AM Eastern time, 10 AM central, 1077 K twins.

[00:36:17] Then hang out with us Wednesday afternoons, on MXTR and house shack radio, 3 PM Eastern time. Then Thursday, get up bright and early with us on 95, seven web radio at 6 AM Pacific time, 9 AM. And then, of course, we've got your Friday covered as well. 12 PM Eastern time on MXTR FM and 10 PM Eastern time, 9 PM central,

[00:36:45] 1077 K twins. Find everything on. If you like small town mystery, crazy news and wild history, then the Florida men on Florida man podcast is for you. Each week, Josh Mills and Wayne McCarty bring you the absolute best Florida has to offer. So if you're looking for a show that's safe for the family, but funny enough to help you escape everyday life,

[00:37:14] then listen to the Florida men on Florida man podcast. That's Florida men plural on Florida man podcast. Do you ever find yourself thinking about who would win in a fight between Goku and Superman? Hi, I'm James Gavsey. And on the who would win show, me and my cohost Ray ignore anything important happening in the outside world and debate fictional battles between characters from comics, movies, and video games. We got a new show every week and almost always. Am I the winner? Not true, Ray in the past.

[00:37:41] We've discussed such matches as captain America versus Darth Vader, solid snake versus the iron giant classic matchups like Robocop versus Terminator, and even the Muppets versus Sesame street. That one was crazy. So if you're a fan of geek culture and love a spirited debate, check out the who would win show, wherever you get your podcasts or check us out at who would win show.com. There's so many other good standalone episodes with rays and dog, it,

[00:38:11] you know, and dog, it actually gets answers. It was like, uh, what, what happened to my son? You know, it was like, he didn't die the way we think he did. And I can come to closure and we actually get to see his wife. He's actually played by, uh, Robert Patrick's real life actress, wife Barbara. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. One of two credits on X files here, but yeah, I mean, when, uh, Gish's, uh, Ray's character, when she's in that hospital in season nine,

[00:38:39] where she is having to hint to, uh, dog it and company. Like she got in that near fatal car crash, you know, just going to work. Someone hit her in a freak car accident. And it's like, and now, Oh yeah, that wasn't planned. That actually happened. Really? Yeah. The cut back cart, that specific scene that you're talking about with skull to getting the, it's in earlier seasons. I can't remember what episode it was,

[00:39:07] but when Scully's walking into the convenience store, a car gets hit. That wasn't planned. That actually happened live while they were, while they were filming it and they left it then. I can't remember what episode that was. Oh, yeah. Well, this one, this is the one where she's like in the hospital purgatory. Oh, okay. But so she didn't get hit by the car. So it's a, but I, but in all fairness,

[00:39:33] I did feel like that was a callback to that particular episode. Uh, but how cool, how we had, what's his name from, uh, Oh, what's his name from Rocky? No, which one? Uh, I, I got his name. Uh, he black. No, Richard Gant. No, I'm sorry. I just, yeah, I love that. He black. Uh, remember,

[00:40:03] I think a Richard Gant. I like him. I just, yeah, no, I loved him. He did good as the, as, as the, as the promoter inspired episode, Don King, but yeah, no, this is Stan Shaw. Who? Oh, okay. Snake eyes. Okay. Rocky. Yeah. I know what you're talking about. Yeah. You've seen him in boys and company C and truck Turner, rising sun throat Island. Oh God. Daylight. I like it. Yeah. Yeah. Still with us.

[00:40:33] Yes. I can't believe it, but yeah. When I would see him show up, I'm like, Hey, yeah, the guy who should have had his bigger career from the Rocky cast, but, um, yeah, he's really good as one of the other guys in this purgatory is like, you could, he was with Stallone again in daylight. Yeah. Yes. Yeah. Yeah. Well, all back. Uh, but, but yeah, that, that whole episode is so underrated. I'm like, everybody should see that episode. I don't care if you don't like season nine. There are so many good standalone episodes. It's like,

[00:41:02] so I can't call it a bad season. I can call it a weaker season. I was okay with X files just staying open, but I'll let you chime in on the second movie. Ethan, someone who did, this book, which I'm not attacking it, but I am going to say, I don't recommend it. Cause you can read most of the reviews on Wikipedia. That's attacking it. That's attacking it. Yeah. man, dude, uh, the,

[00:41:28] this guy had the nerve to say movie two is better than movie one. I like both and I'm going to let you take on it. Oh, why do you think it didn't work for many? Cause I was indifferent when it first came out. Why do you think? I was the same way. I get it, but I rewatched it. Now I feel it's more of a mythos episode. Yeah. It should have been an episode. I will say the ending is rough.

[00:41:53] Cause they kind of still have inconclusive answers and it just isn't cinematic for that crowd. I think they should have given a little more nuts and bolts to it, but yeah, this book by Robert Sherman called wanting to believe a critical guide to the X-Files millennium and lone gunman. I cannot stand this book because a, he hates all the mythology episodes. I'm like, well, why are you, why are you here? That's not even, you're not a real fan. And well,

[00:42:23] you can like what you like, but yeah, like he was liking so many of the well acclaimed ones where I'm like, you gave that a one out of five. Really? Okay. So he's a kiss ass. I guess, but yeah, he didn't seem very interested in either lone gunman or millennium is like, so you did it just to have a full book and say, so you sat on IMDB and read all the positive shit. And there's like, Hey, I'm going to write a book.

[00:42:52] Oh, but what was even more confusing was then he said, my opinions could change the next day. I'm like, so wait, wait, wait, wait, wait. So this might not even be your final opinion, but even then, like he was like, I get on rotten tomatoes and give you a book too. I guess so. But yeah, don't buy the book. Just read the reviews. They're on the Wikipedia pages for some of the episodes. And even then I was like, you hated that. We all, not every episode that's popular is liked by everybody.

[00:43:20] Some find them excessive or too convoluted, but it's like, he was pretty much disliking a good chunk of them to where I'm like, how are you even an X-Files fanatic? So Robert, if you're listening to this, I'm glad you sold the book. I'm just going to leave it there. And while shaking my head, you need to stay off the internet, Robert. Yes. Movie two was 30 million. Once again, and it made 36 points. Christ. 4 million,

[00:43:50] but not, not hot critics. I did watch the director's cut. I think that I'm really surprised at how much gore they got away on a PG 13 is like, we're implying that we're doing a Frankenstein removal of the head, but sorry. He has two thousands. It needed a better ending. Cause I mean, we already got the bad guy from Memento and, you know, Starbucks boyfriend on Battlestar, Calum Keyes, Rennie as the suspect. And you realize he's not the main guy. He's the supplier for this guy taking body parts.

[00:44:17] So it's almost like the movie body parts. I just want to say what's fun. Like to mention about those two movies is like, it's really interesting how different the budgets are on those. Like you have this huge, quite a huge budget for the first one. And then the second one, it's like one of the problems with the second one, it does look too cheap. It's like, it's a fucking summer. And it was July. Yeah. And it was filmed in Canada.

[00:44:46] So somehow it was, I actually didn't mind exhibit or Amanda Pete as the agents. People are in it, but I will say I, you do forget Skinner's in it. Cause he doesn't really come into reinforcement. So I think to make a better movie. Oh yeah. I forgot he was, he is, he comes in as like the final cavalry. So I think it just needed better buildup. They should have made it be less of a slow burn mystery. Yeah. Although it does work for a slow burner mythos though. So that's just it.

[00:45:16] It should have been an episode, not a movie, I think, but basically Chris Carter's thing was with that. As I'm sure you both know, it's like, are people still interested in the X-Files? So that's, yeah, that was the big thing I remember. Which is so crazy. Cause it was airing nonstop. Every year. Like I own that steel book for, I want to believe. I'm jealous. I love it. So good. Um, and I remember watching that dot. I remember watching that interview and he, Chris Carter mentioned it. He's like,

[00:45:46] are people still interested in X-Files? Does it still have a following? Probably kept the budget low. Yeah, that's true. Cause if they'd have went further, you would have had more to it. It would have been, it would have been rivaling fight the future, but they decided to go small budget. Cause a, the series is over. There's nothing left except comics. Yeah. And for six years. Yeah, for real. And B, you still have, you still have the comics,

[00:46:14] you still have the books and all that shit in the games, but see, you know, there's not a lot of talk. And this is just, this is just when my space was taken off. So. It was released the week after the dark night. Oh yeah. The bad timing. It's like, yeah. Every movie that. I agree. No, every movie that. That's what she was doing. And got, and has a cult following,

[00:46:42] look at its release schedule and you'll see the culprit for why it tanked and has a cult. Yeah. Like I'm the lost boys and monster squad in 87. Like they were like on certain days. It's like, you shouldn't have done that. Yeah. It's the same. You guys are completely. All right. Cause then you see revenge movies like. Uh, like John Moore, you know, he's already done plenty of other action films, like behind enemy lines and the Omen remake. And then he does Max Payne. He's like, I want the R rating. And I do think the director's cut.

[00:47:12] R rated cut is the better version of that movie. Even you don't have to like it, but I see that. I liked that. Yeah. Yeah. I was the old. And I got booted by the fans of that, but not many of us like it. Yeah. And it's like, I was expecting a death wish punisher type movie. It's like, I can like both this and punish your words. But people were bashing the director. Cause like he wants an R rating. I'm like, well, Hey, here's the thing. It doesn't. It did. And didn't work for Chris Nolan.

[00:47:40] Cause they cut away when the Joker, you know, impels someone on a pencil and other stuff in dark night. It doesn't work in dark night rises where I can clearly see people getting gunned down or knifed. And then, you know, more than no blood three minutes. And it's like cut away. And people don't give them shit for that. It's like, you guys give so many other people shit for that. What is it with you? Sucking Nolan off? Just it's wild. Why are we doing favoritism? It's like,

[00:48:10] like the rating to like people. It's the rating. It's definitely the politics, but then it's loyalty. It's like, guess what? I love Spielberg. I love almost all his movies, but when he missteps, I say, Hey, better luck next time, Steven. And same thing with, you know, just other people. Like if Dick Wolf produces a bad show, I'm going to be like, Hey, you know, better luck next time. I wish you would do a different show, a different premise. And same thing with all these other guys. Like I saw cop rock. It wasn't good for Steven Bocco, but Hey,

[00:48:39] you know, I also, at the same time, applaud him for not for defending it. It's like, I legit thought it was a good idea. So it was like, same deal. Like same thing with Chris Carter. When he missteps, I applaud him because he defends it. Cop rock. Yeah. I saw the bad. I watched a video. Thank God X-Files wasn't like cop rock. Oh man. Oh Jesus Christ. Scully. We got to solve this mystery. I'm solving alien. Now,

[00:49:09] now, now do you guys, is your mind blown who the original cast would have been? They were thanking Pam Anderson for Scully. And they were thanking Kevin Sorbo for Mulder. And I'm like, what the fuck? Crisis. Hercules and freaking Andromeda. I'm like, Hercules and CJ. Are you fucking kidding me? I'm like, crisis avoided. Cause you know, I like Pamela, but it took her a while to. Her best role. To date. And I'll defend the fuck out of this.

[00:49:37] Her best role was barbed wire. I had fun with it. Okay. Have either of you seen. Oh, fuck. Okay. The title of the show. man, that was crazy. If you heard of the, have you seen the show called stacked? Yes. I would see parts of that. It's actually really good. Forget Brewster was on that. Yeah. Like, Have you seen the series starved? Huh? Have you seen the series starved on FX? Yeah. FX. Yeah, man. That's a good show. Sterling K Brown. Yes.

[00:50:05] I love him in that. And army wives. And that must've really caused some controversy when that came out. I saw it like a few years ago. Yeah. So that, that, that's where the riddle is, is like Carter was already doing edgy stuff like this. I'm surprised he didn't go to FX and do some other mature audience shows that he would have worked good on FX. If they let him review X-Files again, like if you want to bring that back, we can do with a TV. I'm talking even original stuff. I can totally see him doing a workplace, start comedy.

[00:50:35] I like that movie. I don't remember. It took me three tries to watch it. Like the first time I liked, I watched it. I was like, okay, where are the fucking aliens at? No, no. Second time I watched it. I was like, Oh, this is really good. Third time I watched it. I was like, Oh, this is another myth. There was episode as a movie. I love this. It was fucking fuckers. They did one of the best episodes of the TV series as a movie. Exactly.

[00:51:05] I'm with you. And so I went for them recently and I appreciate them both, you know, even more. Like I, when I saw the first movie, I hadn't seen all the seasons. I had seen a bunch. I was like, it's fine. Decent. Appreciate it even more. I see why this was. Uh, uh, you know, a go-to thing, but, but yeah, I, I, I had the on, uh, rated version of movie too. And I recall being indifferent to it. It was like, it, I kind of agreed with the viewers on it. It's like, it's an okay rainy day movie.

[00:51:33] It's just don't expect it to be like a big encompassing thing. But yeah, it went, when you look at what they did there is like, yeah, everybody came in where they needed to. Like Scully wants to walk away. Can't Mulder wants to walk away. Can't Skinner comes in as the reinforcement and then finally arrests, you know, the creepy, but I got to consider when it came out, you know, Oh, wait, everybody's trying to be big. The marble phase is starting. Saw movies are still creeping out.

[00:52:03] People are mine. Dark night. And don't you love how Roger Eber gave both this and the dark night four out of four stars. I saw, he's never seen, he's only seen three episodes. He really liked the first movie, but he loved this one because he's a very religious man. So we loved how it was questioning the social atmosphere. So I saw that movie, but the thing about that summer is I was living in Charlottesville, Virginia at the time.

[00:52:32] And I was, I was even for a writer in his early twenties, I was drinking too much and I was going to see, I saw every single movie that came out in that summer. Oh, you're lucky dog. Well, yes and no. It was very, there were duds out there that saw, but it was pretty, there were some good deep cuts as DVDs taken off and advertising's changing and movies and sports and even politics are shifting. But yeah, go ahead. Sorry,

[00:53:01] I didn't mean to interrupt you. it's, it's just though it's, it's kind of amazing what came out the same summer as the X-File, as I want to believe. It's like, no wonder, no wonder that movie didn't do great. Like it opened the same fucking month as Tropic Thunder. Yeah. Tropic Thunder. Iron Man. Yeah. Incredible Hulk. And no way it was kind of just an okay year, but there was just a lot of different, just kind of. There's a lot of big marquee movies. Yeah.

[00:53:31] The show's been off the air. I saw that. Oh, what a double feature, but it's like, so the show's been off the air for five years. The awesome zombie filled video game with Easter eggs to the different towns, you know, resist or serve. Yeah. I watched that. I got to rewatch it actually. Really a lot of fun. So it's like four years, you know, comics are going to start up five years after this, but it's so amazing how at that point people were just sharing their DVDs. It's like, Oh, you never,

[00:54:00] you gave up TV years ago. It's because that that's what I find so funny is like, I kind of got a similar, just when I saw the Stargate guys in interviews, people just, especially comic book shop owners and people who hosted cosplay events, they would share the DVDs with like their theater troops or school and work pals. And it's amazing. And it was amazing how syndication, it was here and there for X-Files, but just probably on local Fox affiliates. TNT. TNT and sci-fi channels showed it for a while and then kind of stopped.

[00:54:28] And then you saw it on El Raid Network and chiller. But again, just kind of here and there, it was kind of just word of mouth. Like now it's got its own channel. Yeah. On Pluto. It's got one of those Pluto TVs. That's right. I'm going to have to tell my aunt and uncle, please. Yeah. I, you remember some good and remember some bad, just have it on 24 seven. You'll remember why you liked it again. You got to look at all the things that TV got away with too, that you can't. That's, that's what I was,

[00:54:56] I was talking about yesterday was some of the stuff they did have back then. There used to always be a TV version of a movie. I thought to myself, how are they getting away with this? I'm trying to find. Yeah. Well, do you, do you guys remember home was the, very first television. It was the very first television episode to have a warning before. Yes. Yeah. No other show had ever done that. And. They only did it once. And then.

[00:55:26] And they only aired it once and they didn't air it again. So that was, that was a major. I loved that, that they took those kinds of leaps with those shows. I love with X-Files in general, that they did that. Yeah. I mean, it's just kind of like every good show. People are getting the wrong message where they're like, Hey, I wonder what else I can get away with. I'm like, well, here's the thing. That's just how they have to tell the story. The story came first. Yes. It just happened to get a little brutal. You had people who don't like gory stuff still watching this.

[00:55:56] So that says something. I still have problems watching. I do too. Yeah. I watched it again. You know, I'm just glad. It's a hell of an episode. Otherwise it wouldn't be. Yeah. Other. If there weren't as much humor as there is in it, I don't think we'd be able to get through it. A thousand percent. But then again, I'll be honest. I'm a horror chick as well. So I have seen extreme horror that has literally made me want to puke. So. I'm not a horror person. Oh, well, but that's what's so cool. Is this like,

[00:56:25] it brings everyone together. And we were joking in another chat. How is like Chris Carter and the writers weren't sci-fi horror guys or even Mr. No, but they're just, but we just, that's just where we have to pigeonhole it. Cause we're, we're telling a dark town. Yes. It's not just a masters of horror or twilight zone episode. It's all, it's all kinds of stuff. And. Yeah. And. Speaking on censorship is like, now they don't even edit movies anymore for TV,

[00:56:55] which just makes it so dumb. There always used to be a cool, like they put deleted scenes back in. Right. Now I don't get that. It's like, I don't have a PG version of this excellent movie that I can show someone who wants to see it. And. I actually was discussing that with someone recently about Ghostbusters and about the television version of Ghostbusters. Literally. Yeah. They had literally filmed scenes so that it could be aired on television. And. You know, it's. And you can find that.

[00:57:24] It's probably on V. Someone's VHS somewhere. So. Isn't it on the Blu-ray now? I think they added some of those. Oh, it might be. Yeah. It might be. Cause I always remember. When. When. When. When. When they come out of the dining room with the. With the trap. Right. When. Originally when Peter walks out, he says, we came, we saw, we kicked it. It's a. But in the television. It's what a knockabout of pure fun. That was. Yeah. Completely different. Yes. That they had actually record.

[00:57:55] Recorded. Instead of just dubbing over or something like that. So. It's interesting. We're bringing it up, but it's kind of like what they did with. I want to believe. Yes. Yes. We should bring that up. Yes. Yeah. That's a good segue for movie two. Yeah. I. I personally. From. Watching the first one. And. Have. Gone through it so many times. And analyzed it. When I saw this version.

[00:58:23] There wasn't that much scary stuff in it. No. No. They could have put in the original. But. The part that I didn't like was. The editing. It was like. It was awful. The Mulder and Skully. Part of it. Needed to be in that version of it. There it is. I'm with you. They cut pieces off. And then it didn't make. You know. Right. Right. Like they took out those. Or whatever. It's just. It's like. The scene.

[00:58:53] It would just like. Jump. Into something else. Yeah. Yeah. And it's like. We needed that final scene. Where they're reflecting on life. It's like. Is there no other scene. Reflecting on that. Because like. I'm glad that you. Teetered over the annoying stuff. With the killers. And the priest. But. Yeah. Now it's going way too fast. Where now I feel like I'm reading a. Watching a Cliff Notes version of it. So. I really do. Right. Yeah. Why did they wait? I thought that. It lost meaning. Yeah.

[00:59:22] Well I think it. But what would it be to somebody who's never seen it? That's what I'm wondering. If I went now. You know. Yeah. Yeah. It's like. That's an action packed episode. But then. The Frankenstein. That's the thing that could have been on TV. The dog. The two had a dog made better since this time. But. Yes it did. It did. Yes. But then like you're saying is like. Okay. So. Some people didn't like the supporting stuff. But I'm like. Well. That was still pretty key on Scully's character. So I mean. Yes.

[00:59:52] Well the way I saw the films was. The original theatrical release. I remember enjoying it because I enjoyed. The relationship. Relationship between Scully and Mulder. And that. Yeah. That to me was what was key. Was them furthering the relationship. And that was what the first film was. Yeah. And it was. It was. And the. The Father Joe situation. And the boy. And the Russian scientist. That was sort of. That was a helper. Along with what was happening to them. Right.

[01:00:22] And I felt. And I felt like with the. With the retake. They cut back on that relationship stuff. In places where I don't think he should have cut it. I think that's right. That bed scene. That bed scene should have stayed. That entire bed scene should have stayed. That. And yes. By bed scene. You're referring to which scene exactly? Sorry. I'm just. Where they're both. When they were. And they're talking. Oh. They're talking about the boy. Yeah. They're talking about the boy. They're talking about William. Yeah. They're talking about William and the boy. Yeah. And this new one.

[01:00:52] Cut that. That's totally out. All of a sudden. All we see. All we see. All we see. Oh that was weird. Now I can't sleep. And it's like. Yeah. That makes no sense. Yeah. He jumps up and shows you. You're like. Why is he shaving at four o'clock in the morning? It doesn't explain. That's where it makes me wonder. It doesn't explain why he shaved. Yeah. No. Some other editor or filmmaker had come in and done it. Or is Chris too close to it? I don't. I really don't know. I don't know what they were thinking. Because I had more fun. Because the gruesome stuff is out.

[01:01:20] But then the character development also went out. So I'm like. It did. Right. What the hell? Well and also I think the editing was far better on the action scenes. I thought the editing was far better. Yeah. Oh yeah. As far as fun. I could see it better. I thought. Yeah. And the music was more consistent. The possibility was perfect. Right. The music was more consistent. It was. Yes. The music was more consistent. It sounded like a Nine Inch Nails score. But then. Yeah. Like you say. It's like. We take these 20 extra minutes away of every scene.

[01:01:50] Yeah. So I'm like. Okay. Cool. So Skinner didn't feel like a second nature. Coming out of nowhere. Right. Because my issue with that was. Where's he been this whole time? Yeah. Me too. And then. Yes. I'm glad we didn't see. Mulder take forever. Getting knocked out off the highway. But. Yeah. And. The Frankenstein thing is still in like the last 20 minutes. Could it be hinted at earlier? Could they replace some dialogue? I don't. I don't know. Yeah. I don't know. And. Is this a non-fixable movie? It was a hard one. No. I don't know.

[01:02:20] I think. What he did. It's. I don't know what they were thinking when they did this. I think it's a hard thing in general. Because I. I remember people really not liking the movie. And. When it first came out. It wasn't. I wasn't one. It wasn't. I didn't like it. And well. Yeah. And I. I liked it okay. But what I liked was. It's a rainy day movie. But yeah. Yeah. It's not. But I liked the relationship situation. That's what I enjoyed. Yes. That's what he was.

[01:02:51] Yeah. And I think. And I felt like everything else was. I felt like. Especially the chase scenes were too dragged out. And that sort of thing. But. I just think that he cut too much. And I just. Yeah. That. Yeah. I don't. I don't understand. What I don't understand. I want to ask Chris. And say. What exactly was your purpose. Originally. Right. And why didn't you get that across originally? Was it simply because they wanted a PG-13 rating? Is that the only reason? Because that doesn't seem like. I think that's. That's the PG-13. Because.

[01:03:21] Yeah. Being that I worked for a studio. That's the main thing. Oh it's huge. Yeah. To get something out is. Not to get that R rating. I agree. I agree. If they don't. If they. If they don't. If they get that R rating. They can't. Do it. They can't get the money that they want to get. So they'll cut. What they need to cut. Per the. Per the. And it's a light R. That was the other thing. That was so light R. Yeah. Very light.

[01:03:51] Yeah. I thought it would be way gorier. And I thought it was going to be crazy gory. Yeah. Me too. I thought it was going to be gross. The only thing that I thought was. Gory was the fact that. They chopped up the body. Yeah. Yeah. That was mostly what the gory was. Yes. Yeah. Exactly. Well they also showed the. The Whitney. See. When she landed at the elevator. They actually showed her landing on the. Oh no. They landed on the first one. Yeah. Well. No. No. It wasn't. So. So here's the thing. Storyteller. You're.

[01:04:20] You're talking about the uncut version of movie too. It's like yes. I own that version. It does. Okay. Does it really? Right. Yeah.

[01:04:28] It does show that in the uncut. A TV episode. But. That's what it was. Yeah.

[01:04:56] But the ending is still the problem. Is like. I. Yeah. It's like. It leaves you with something. But not a full deal. There were some people who liked it. Roger Ebert of all people. Had barely seen an episode. Gave him four out of four stars. Because he's a spiritual guy. Oh Lord. Right. I know. So I was just like. So. And I have other fans who were like. Fuck that movie. Fuck it. It's terrible. But then. I'm just like. You know. It's. Interesting. It's just. Yes. But there's still something missing. I don't know what it is. Yeah.

[01:05:26] I don't. I sometimes. I saw it from an editing. Perspective. Okay. But. I think that's what. Disturbished the. Continuity of the. Story. But it was. Obvious. Like. The scene where they're visiting. Priest. Father Joe. Right. And then as. Boulder and. Scully are leaving. Scully refused to go. He hands her the vial. Yeah.

[01:05:56] Why would he do that? And then. All of a sudden. In this movie. They're playing. Flanade. In the. Operating room. And then. All of a sudden. She's. In her office. Prying. Oh yeah. Yeah. And then she. Goes for the vial. Yeah. That was a bad editing. It's like. Yeah. What vial is she going to go for? Why? And then all of a sudden. She's in bed. Oh I went over that report. You gave me. When? Yeah. Yeah. It's. It's something. But sorry. You're going to say something Laura.

[01:06:25] Well I was going to say. They even cut out. There was a scene where they had the argument. About him. Going back into the X-Files. And him wanting to drag her back into the X-Files. Yeah. And she talked about how she. Why she fell in love with him. Yes. And they chopped that out. They chopped that out. That was a great thing. Yeah. And the part where she was in the locker room. They came out. Yes. They totally chopped the part out. We have a poop. Yes. Yes. That too. Yes.

[01:06:55] Totally chopped that out. Well they chopped out the kiss at the end. The kiss at the end was gone. And it was like. You've got to be kidding me. What. What are you doing here? You know. I. I didn't understand that at all. I really didn't. I. It's one of those things where I just don't understand what Chris was thinking. And I don't think it came across with his new edited version. And I. I. I don't either. Yeah. I just. It's one of those things where I wish I could sit down and answer. A broken record. Yeah. Yeah. Right. Exactly. In the uncut version.

[01:07:23] As much as I don't like the killer stuff. The utter going around the town and asking questions is still vital. So. And like you're saying. Yes. The questions asking about William. That. We're confusing the people who had already given up by season eight and nine. You know. It's like. Right. Right. Yeah. I think that was part of it too. That may have been part of why people didn't like it as well. It's because there is a lot of stuff in the film that if you didn't watch the entire series. Right. You probably aren't going to understand it. Right. Right. It's not like. It's not like when fight the future.

[01:07:53] Fight the future. I went with a friend who had never watched X-Files before. And she understood the film perfectly. Great standalone. And that's the thing that I liked about fight the future was. You didn't have to be a fan. No. No you didn't. You can go into that movie and. Totally get it. Yeah. Yeah. It was a very, very, very well done movie. Absolutely. Yes. Out of both of those movies. That's my favorite of all. Mine too. Me too. Oh yeah. Love that film.

[01:08:23] And that's what I was expecting with I Want to Believe. Oh. Me too. Because I don't know if you remember the advertisements back then. The promos. Because they didn't have social media back then. Basically. No we didn't. Yeah. What you got off of the internet. And they would have like photos of Mulder as a werewolf. I don't know if you remember. I did not. Oh yeah. I do remember. That's right. I had forgotten about that. Yeah. That they had.

[01:08:53] Because he had the beard. So people thought that that was where it was going to go. But in the promos he was like as a werewolf. And it was just like they're not going to say anything. And the scene where the actual promo where there's sitting at a computer. Yes. He's sitting at a computer and Scully is saying. And she's over the site. It's not even in the movie. I just posted that. Yeah. I posted that on my page today. And it's not in the movie. It is.

[01:09:21] Because I noticed that's the screenshot on Hulu. Yeah. When you bring up the film. And it's like that's not even in the film. I mean it's clearly filmed during that time. Because of Scully's hair. But yeah. It isn't in the film at all. I know. Studios do that all the time. Sometimes when I did work. They would have these incredible songs. That's true. You have to pay the song before you. Whether you're going to use it or not. Right.

[01:09:50] Oh speaking of. Yeah. And so to license them. Some of the songs were like over a million dollars. Right. Yeah. I told myself. I'm going to go see this movie just so I can hear that song. And I would go. And I would go. And that song was not even in that movie. Yeah. They paid for that little bit to play in the promo. Not even 60 seconds. Like with the. Yeah. Like they just did with 28 Days Later. Or 28 Years Later. Where they used the boots. Rudyard Kipling's. Oh my god.

[01:10:20] I love that poem. But they used that poem in the promo. And then it was never in the film. And I was like. You just made the best trailer ever. And the film sucked. To me it did. But I was really looking forward to that movie. Because of what they did with the trailer. And I was very disappointed. I didn't like. I didn't like it at all. I thought it was ridiculous. See. That's. I like the first two. That's kind of a trick. I like the first two. Yeah it is a trick. In the movie. In the movie business. If they know they have a really bad film. Yeah.

[01:10:49] They will make the best trailer. That totally makes it. That makes. Yeah. Make people go see it. Well just like we've joked for years. How many movies that didn't feel like Star Trek. Even Hellraiser. Oh yeah. Right. It was like just put the character in. It's the same. So I think that's the main complaint about movie two. Is. Yes. And I almost wish Howard Gordon had come back. Because he always was really good at doing all the spiritual and religious episodes. And. Oh that's true. One of the biggest issues about movie two is.

[01:11:18] It almost feels like they're trying to make the former pedophile turned psychic priest be redeemed. It's like I'm sorry. That's just. I'm not willing to go that route. You know. It's a pedophile still a pedophile. You know. I think. I think it was just an interesting commentary. Yeah. No. What he says is interesting. The Catholic faith. And how it works. You know. That's what I saw it as. The Catholic faith is very interesting. Yes. Yeah. It is. Because of her faith and doctor. Yes. Relationship. Yeah. Yeah.

[01:11:46] And how she relates to being a woman of faith. But then on the other side being a scientist and a doctor. Yes. Which is going completely against each other. Right. Which can. That's for sure. Yeah. I appreciate that Chris did take the time to try to make the film he wanted to make. But I also think it's also a little too little too late at this point. Yes. Yes. I think it would have been better just to leave it alone.

[01:12:14] And I've heard him talk about wanting to do another film. Yes. I've been reading that too. Yeah. And to me. I don't know if the ratings are going to give him the numbers or budget he needs. Yeah. That's what I was wondering. Yeah. Because you don't get near the amount of money from streaming that you would from. No. Right. Right. And is he trying to see if there's an audience for another film? I guess so. And I'm like, I don't think you went about that the right way. I don't think so, unfortunately. I mean, I would watch it. Us diehards will watch it. Yes.

[01:12:43] Do you guys have anything you'd love to promote by any chance? Anything. Is there no one else? My account. That's it. Yeah. Laura, anything. That's interesting. That sounds really good. I love me some true crime. And who better than people who witnessed it and processed it? Yes. Yeah. There's so many underdog stories, like you're saying. It's like, hey, you know, this is delightful, guys. What kind of content do you do? Dinosaur Woman. Oh, yeah. Your content. Oh, me?

[01:13:13] Well, my name is Andrea Thomas. Yes. I'm Dinosaur Woman. Andrea Thomas. Yeah. And it's, I, Dinosaur Woman is just a fun name that I have. But I. You're not going extinct anytime soon. No, I'm not going extinct anytime soon. I'll be Dinosaur Woman 93 on. Um, I'm on Instagram and threads. That's what I was trying to look up. Yeah. It's Dinosaur Woman 93. I probably should have been 93 on there. Um, I'm, you know, I talk about movies that I like.

[01:13:43] Um, I used to get into kind of political. We don't talk. We don't talk about stuff. Yeah, I know. But I, I mean, I used to get into political stuff and stuff like that, but I don't anymore. But I do. Um, if you are interested, I also, I run, I'm a publisher and editor. I run Dark Owl Publishing. Uh, that I've got, but I don't, I'm not a traditional publisher in the sense of I'm trying to help authors get their books out there, uh, rather than trying to meet a quota or. Just give a voice for the underdog.

[01:14:11] Yeah, and, and, and all of my authors are really varied guys. I've got. You're the underground publisher. Yeah. I've got right-wing Christians and I've got gay guys and I've got, you know, left-wing men and, and women on both sides. So it's a huge, it is really diverse in that sense. It is a large amount of types of people, but what I publish is sci-fi, horror, and fantasy that just appeals to anyone. So it's sorry. I just published. Very cool.

[01:14:41] Oh, thanks. Yeah. My goal is to, is just to publish books that are good. So you are the real life X-Files for real. That's great. Yes. I will say that. Yeah. And a lot of the stuff is, it's good for teenagers on up. So I, I don't publish anything that's, you know, extreme, no, no, uh, spicy romance or anything like that. So I try to, I try to publish stuff that everybody can enjoy and that, um, and that, you know, has some mystery and intelligence to it as well. Um, and you know, yeah, kind of like the X-Files.

[01:15:11] It's in its own way. So, um, and then I also have, so Dark Owl was on Stubstack and mostly I talk about writing and storytelling, um, and how to do those things. But I haven't been on in a little while just because I'm redoing my website right now. So it's been, that's been a process. I've had another friend too. She wrote a Moonlighting cookbook. She took recipes from the show and made it different things. She's heard in the show. Like she's made cocktail drinks out of them. She's got steak all a day.

[01:15:38] She's got a vision, vision virgin drink that was in the show. Is it one that will cure all cancers? Uh, it would. Thank you. Look for these in October. Like show running is not easy business as people with like four hours of sleep. It is so tough. Exactly. Like, you know, Chris Carter is himself. Like those are the busiest years of my life. You know, lots of, you know, like you had to work on, you know, the feature film, the X-Files.

[01:16:03] I can only imagine the mixed reaction the second movie had. I can only wonder if people either sat, clapped or just were silent. But either way, he's like, hey, you came and saw what you did. I'm just going to let it speak for itself. This is like, I'm not going to get. There were, there were four people in the theater that I saw the X. I want to believe in. Oh man. There were four other people. And I can say we all seem to think it was fine. It was kind of like, I remember, I remember looking at it and I was like, yeah, it was all right.

[01:16:33] And everybody, this is why. That's a good point. I was looking forward to doing all these chats. I have all these different group chats as we're setting up the recordings. Everybody was chill. Everybody had different takes, but no one was, you know, starting a shit storm. Unlike other fandom where it's like, how could you like that? So it was like, yeah, they just like, hey, I did not care for it. Glad you liked it. It's like, I also don't interact with fandoms. So I wouldn't, I, I, I'm just saying it's way more civil, but fair enough.

[01:17:01] No, no, I, I just try to just be orderly. Just strike it where it is. Follow us on the web on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram. The podcast is available on Podbean, Spotify, iHeartRadio, Anchor, Apple, and anywhere else podcasts are available. Feel free to review our show and leave comments on any of those sites.

[01:17:30] Thanks a million for listening. It's a Jacked Up Review Show. All right.